Skip navigation

Bayonet Plumbing, Heating & Air Conditioning Blog

Do Central AC or Heat Pumps Need More Repairs?


If you are considering a new cooling system, you’ve probably heard about heat pumps. These are an alternative to traditional central air conditioning systems and are available in both ducted and ductless models, offering great flexibility. However, heat pumps can be more expensive than central air conditioning.

Homeowners in Florida often want to know the answer to an important question, “Do central air conditioning systems or heat pumps need more repairs?” This is an essential consideration to take into account since you’ll have to live with your new system for the next 10-15 years, and the need for air conditioning repair in Wesley Chapel should be factored into the overall cost. Let’s explain.

How Heat Pumps and Central Air Conditioning Systems Work

Heat pumps and central air conditioning systems use the same technology, which can confuse homeowners who think heat pumps operate differently. Both systems compress refrigerant and have a similar setup with indoor and outdoor units. 

The main difference is the reversing valve in heat pumps, which allows them to switch between cooling and heating, providing year-round comfort. This valve can sometimes fail due to wear and tear, but it is an easy fix for our experienced HVAC technicians. Regular maintenance can prevent most reversing valve issues which should be scheduled twice a year for both ducted and ductless heat pumps.

Factors Influencing Repair Needs

Several factors can affect the repair needs of both systems. Proper sizing and professional installation are crucial for optimal performance. Regularly changing the air filter every 1-3 months is essential for both systems. Ductless heat pumps (or mini split systems) require cleaning each air handler’s filter, which can be time-consuming if you have multiple handlers.

Tips for Minimizing Repairs and Extending Lifespan

Regular maintenance is key to reducing repairs and extending the lifespan of both systems. Heat pumps need maintenance twice a year because they are used year-round, similar to a combination of a central furnace and AC system. Central AC systems require maintenance only once a year. If you tend to skip out on maintenance, a central AC system is the better option.

The Bottom Line

In Florida, with its long cooling seasons, the frequency of AC repairs is an important consideration. No homeowner wants to be without air conditioning during a heat wave. When choosing between central AC and heat pumps, consider factors beyond repair costs, such as energy efficiency, lifespan, and overall performance. 

If you’re unsure which system is best for your home, contact us for an honest assessment that takes into additional factors such as your family makeup, type of home, and long-term goals for your property.

Whatever type of AC system you have, when it needs any type of repair, we have expert technicians trained to handle all types of problems any type and model of air conditioner on the market. Whether it’s an immediate emergency or you think your system just isn’t working as it should, we’ll send someone out quickly to pinpoint the problem and perform any necessary repairs.

Contact Bayonet Plumbing, Heating & Air Conditioning to schedule air conditioning repair in Clearwater, FL today!

Comments are closed.